California's housing market just posted one of its weakest months in years, and the people who have been running the state do not get to treat that as a surprise.
On Tuesday, the California Association of REALTORS (C.A.R.) reported that existing single-family home sales fell to a seasonally adjusted annual rate of 246,830 in October, down 5.2 percent from 260,410 in September and down 12.7 percent from 282,760 in October 2025. It was the lowest sales pace in nearly three years, C.A.R. said, and the largest annual decline since September 2023. Statewide sales have now stayed below the 300,000-unit benchmark for 49 straight months. The statewide median price was $886,760, down 1.4 percent from $899,720 in September and essentially unchanged from $887,330 a year earlier, ending five straight months of annual gains.
The slowdown was broad. Sales fell on a year-over-year basis in all five major regions C.A.R. tracks, with Southern California down 18.9 percent, the Central Valley down 14.9 percent, the Far North down 14.8 percent, and the San Francisco Bay Area down 12.1 percent. Six of seven price segments posted double-digit annual declines. Homes priced from $750,000 to $999,999 had the sharpest drop, 20.7 percent; the $2 million-and-above segment was the only one to rise, and only by 0.7 percent. The unsold inventory index rose to 3.8 months, from 3.7 in September and 3.2 a year earlier, as active listings slipped 1.4 percent from September but remained 6.6 percent above October 2025. Homes that did sell went for 98.5 percent of list price.
C.A.R. was blunt about the immediate trigger. The 30-year fixed mortgage rate averaged 7.33 percent in October, up from 6.86 percent in September and 6.25 percent a year earlier, according to C.A.R.'s calculations based on Freddie Mac data, reaching its third-highest monthly average in 26 years. "When mortgage rates jumped to a nearly three-year high in late September, we saw many buyers step back and reassess what they could afford, which led to fewer closed sales in October," said 2027 C.A.R. President Mark Peterson. Prices, he added, "held steady." Chief economist Jordan Levine said sales "will likely remain soft in the near term, but pent-up demand continues to build as many prospective buyers stay on the sidelines."
https://twitter.com/nypost/status/2123071438613516299
Rates matter. They do not explain why so few Californians could afford a typical house even before this latest spike, or why the state is still producing only a fraction of the homes its own leaders said would be needed.
C.A.R.'s Housing Affordability Index, released Oct. 30, found that only 19 percent of California households could afford the $894,630 median-priced existing single-family home in the third quarter of 2026, unchanged from the second quarter and from a year earlier. A household needed a minimum income of $228,000 to make the $5,700 monthly payment, including principal, interest, taxes, and insurance, as the effective 30-year rate rose to 6.80 percent. C.A.R. said that income threshold has now exceeded $200,000 in 15 of the past 16 quarters, and that California's monthly housing payment remained more than twice the national average of $2,760. For a median $640,000 condo or townhome, 31 percent of households could qualify. In Los Angeles County, the index was 15 percent, with a $958,450 median, a $6,100 payment, and a $244,000 qualifying income. Nationwide, 39 percent of households could afford a $432,900 median home.
Gov. Gavin Newsom, Democratic legislative supermajorities, and Democratic officials in the state's largest cities have had years to change that picture. The Newsom administration's planning target is more than 2.5 million homes over the current housing cycle, including at least one million affordable homes, a figure the governor's office has said is more than double the previous cycle and a comedown from the 3.5 million homes Newsom campaigned on in 2017, as CalMatters has noted. Spread over eight years, CalMatters wrote in August, that 2.5 million target works out to 312,500 homes a year. The U.S. Census Bureau's final 2025 Building Permits Survey counted 103,856 new privately owned housing units authorized in California, up only slightly from 101,545 in 2024. That left California third among states in raw permits, behind Texas (210,217) and Florida (178,297), and at about one-third of the annual pace implied by the state's own goal. CalMatters also found that, halfway through much of Southern California's planning cycle, only five jurisdictions in the entire state were permitting at a pace to hit all four of their income-level targets.
Democratic leaders have a fair rebuttal, and it should be stated plainly. C.A.R. itself tied October's slump to the late-September rate jump. Nationally, the National Association of REALTORS reported on Nov. 12 that existing-home sales fell 5.5 percent in October to a 3.75 million annual rate, the lowest since August 2010, with the West down 9.7 percent on the month and 14.5 percent from a year earlier. On June 30, 2025, Newsom signed AB 130 and SB 131, budget bills that created a CEQA exemption for qualifying urban infill housing, sped up some permitting clocks, and marked what the governor's office called the most consequential housing and infrastructure reform in recent state history; the package took effect July 1, 2025. A housing department spokesperson told CalMatters the new laws have already been used to "advance approved projects representing thousands of proposed homes," and that whether a project actually gets built also depends on interest rates, construction and land costs, capital, insurance, and expected rents or sale prices. Those points are real. They do not erase decades of CEQA litigation, slow local approvals, and underbuilding on the same party's watch, and they are too new to explain away a 2025 permit total that still sat far below the state's stated need.
The insurance market has made buying and holding a California home harder still. State Farm, the state's largest homeowners writer, stopped taking new homeowners business in May 2023; Allstate had closed to new residential business in 2022. Those decisions, Insurance Commissioner Ricardo Lara's department said in a Sept. 18, 2026, release, "came to define the state's property insurance crisis." The California FAIR Plan, the insurer of last resort, had 698,307 policies in force as of September 2026, up 8 percent from a year earlier and up 157 percent since September 2022, with $773 billion in total exposure, up 252 percent over those four years. State Farm and Allstate filed plans in September 2026 to start writing new policies again, in State Farm's case for homes meeting certain wildfire-hardening standards, but Lara's department said at the time that the filings were still under review and that the companies were "not open for new business yet."
People have been voting with the moving van. The California Department of Finance estimated net domestic out-migration at 288,600 in 2025. Finance also reported that the state's population slipped 0.14 percent, or about 54,000 people, to 39,593,000 as of Jan. 1, 2026, the first annual decline after three years of gains. The department's own explanation for that overall dip should be included: it said restrictive federal policy cut legal international migration to California by more than half, to 126,400, and that without those federal changes the state would have grown by about 66,000. Los Angeles County lost 64,000 people, a drop Finance attributed to the Eaton and Palisades wildfires, the usual flow toward the Inland Empire, and deportations. Domestic out-migration is the cleaner measure of residents leaving for other states, and it got worse last year.
Local Democratic housing policy has left its own marks. A May 2026 RAND study of Los Angeles Measure ULA, the voter-approved "mansion tax" on high-value property transfers, found that the tax had raised $1.2 billion for affordable housing and tenant assistance through early 2026, but had also reduced high-value real estate sales by 31 percent and housing production by more than 9,000 units, with $452 million in forgone revenue to Los Angeles and associated agencies.
And for all the money spent on the streets that sit beside this housing shortage, the state's own auditor has said Sacramento cannot tell whether the spending works. In an April 9, 2024, report, State Auditor Grant Parks cited the Legislative Analyst's Office finding that the state allocated nearly $24 billion for homelessness and housing from fiscal years 2018-19 through 2022-23. Parks found that the California Interagency Council on Homelessness had not consistently tracked costs and outcomes. Of five programs the auditor reviewed, Homekey and the CalWORKs Housing Support Program appeared cost-effective; three others, which had collectively received more than $9.4 billion since 2020, did not have enough outcome data to judge. The auditor's fact sheet said more than 180,000 Californians experienced homelessness in 2023, a 53 percent increase from 2013.
October's closed sales will not stay at a 246,830 annual pace forever, and C.A.R. is already talking about buyers waiting on the sidelines. The deeper problem is the one Democratic leadership has had the power to confront for years: a median house that 81 percent of California households still cannot afford, a building pace that is not close to the state's own 2.5 million-home target, an insurance residual market that has more than doubled in four years, and a long line of people leaving anyway.



