Buttercups, if you only had one shot at a debate stage to change a governor's race, this is the kind of night you'd want. Republican Steve Hilton came out swinging against Democrat Xavier Becerra at CNN's Burbank studio on Wednesday, and a lot of the commentary is saying he made the most of it.
Jake Tapper and Dana Bash moderated the hour-long debate, the only scheduled one before the November 3 election.
The moments people are talking about
Hilton's best-circulated moment was a confrontation over the roughly 85,000 migrant children the federal refugee office couldn't reach during Becerra's time as Health and Human Services secretary. His campaign's clip of that exchange has racked up hundreds of thousands of views.
https://twitter.com/SteveHiltonx/status/2105474028362146042
There was also a sharper back-and-forth over immigration. Becerra invoked immigrants "who look like me," and Hilton fired back that it was "disgraceful." Hilton also drew a laugh with a one-liner reported by RealClearPolitics. When Becerra reached for the "definition of insanity" line, Hilton shot back, "Like voting Democrat."
RealClearPolitics called the night "seemingly a draw," and said Hilton's strongest stretch came when he asked why voters keep re-electing the people who got California here. Hilton also pressed Becerra on donations tied to AI companies OpenAI and Anthropic.
Right-leaning commentators were less diplomatic. The New York Post's Joel Pollak graded it "An A for Hilton, an F for Becerra," though that is his opinion, and even he added that it "probably won't matter." Tomi Lahren put it more bluntly: "Steve Hilton ATE tonight!"
If you want the greatest hits, here's a highlight reel making the rounds on X:
https://twitter.com/Aidinism/status/2105495297006969338
The other side of the story
Becerra's whole game plan was to tie Hilton to Donald Trump, and by CalMatters' and KQED's accounts, Trump was the main character of the night. The SF Standard said Hilton threw "punch after punch" but that none landed hard enough to change the race.
And the race, as of now, leans Becerra. A UC Berkeley IGS poll of likely voters had him ahead 58% to 33%, and a PPIC poll had it 60% to 38%. No outlet we found called Becerra the clear winner, but his lead is intact.
So here's where it stands, buttercups. Hilton got the clips, the headlines and the cheering section. Becerra still has the numbers. With a few weeks to go, the question is whether a good night on a debate stage can move a race that's been this lopsided.
Photo: Gage Skidmore / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0



